31st May 2024

At The Cash: Concentrated Portfolios:  Andrew Slimmon, Morgan Stanley (Might 8, 2024)

Are your costly lively mutual funds and ETFs truly lively? Or, as is simply too usually the case, are they solely pretending to be lively? Do they cost a excessive lively price however then behave extra like an index fund? AndrewToday, we talk about some great benefits of concentrated portfolios. If you wish to personal lively funds, then be certain they differ its benchmarks and really are lively.

Full transcript beneath.


About this week’s visitor:

Andrew Slimmon is Managing Director at Morgan Stanley Funding Administration, and leads the Utilized Fairness Advisors staff; he serves as Senior Portfolio Supervisor for all lengthy fairness methods.

For more information, see:

Private Bio

Masters in Enterprise recording




Discover the entire earlier On the Cash episodes right here, and within the MiB feed on Apple Podcasts, YouTube, Spotify, and Bloomberg.


Barry Ritholtz: What number of shares do you have to personal to actually be diversified? The quantity might be quite a bit decrease than you suppose. Concentrated portfolios are the other of bropad market indexes or funds and ETFs. They solely personal, A handful of shares, sometimes 203-Zero names. The objective is to personal one of the best performers with out the entire lifeless weight.

I’m Barry Ritholtz, and on right now’s version of At The Cash, we’re going to debate whether or not or not it is best to personal a concentrated portfolio.

To assist us unpack all of this and what it means in your holdings, let’s usher in Andrew Slimmon. He’s the Managing Director at Morgan Stanley Funding Administration, the place he leads the Utilized Fairness Advisors staff and serves as Senior Portfolio Supervisor for all of Morgan Stanley’s lengthy fairness methods. His staff manages about Eight billion in consumer property. Slimmon’s portfolios have finished properly towards the indexes and his international portfolio has trounced the benchmarks. Let’s begin with the fundamentals. What precisely is a concentrated portfolio?

Andrew Slimmon: As I take into consideration a concentrated portfolio, it means two issues. As you mentioned, it may be a restricted variety of positions. So, you already know, 10 to 20 shares is will be concentrated or it might imply a a restricted variety of what I’d name directional place. So if you consider the S&P 500 has a lot of completely different sectors, you can have a whole lot of shares, however say you place them multi function or two sectors, you’ll, you’ll have a concentrated portfolio just because it had made a directional, positioning versus a extra diversified state of affairs.

Barry Ritholtz: So what are some great benefits of having only a few shares or only a few sectors? How does that generate higher returns than the market?

Andrew Slimmon: You probably have a restricted variety of shares, you’re looking for one of the best one of the best shares, uh, in that group and get rid of the, you already know, the canine.  I feel that there’s a profit to that, however what’s vital is to be sure that your positions are diversified. What’s perverse about that is I might have 10 shares and be extra diversified then if I owned 100 shares, as a result of so long as these 10 shares don’t zig and zag the opposite, they, they is likely to be in numerous sectors; they is likely to be completely different — some is likely to be development or worth or defensive., I is likely to be extra diversified proudly owning 10 shares than if I owned tons and plenty of shares that, you already know, which can be extremely correlated. So I feel, It’s a mixture of the variety of positions, however whether or not you diversify, which I’m absolutely in favor of actually is dependent upon what’s the correlation, the relationships of the shares and the portfolios.

Barry Ritholtz: So there’s no magic quantity the place at X variety of shares, you’re actually diversified. It is dependent upon. the businesses themselves, the sectors they’re in what numerous components and qualities they’ve. Is {that a} honest technique to describe that?

Andrew Slimmon: That’s precisely proper. That’s precisely proper. Right here’s an amazing instance. We personal in our fund NVIDIA, however we additionally personal MasterCard and also you’d say, Oh wow, NVIDIA is, you already know, a tech firm. It’s a semiconductor firm. Uh, and MasterCard is a finance, Transactional firm. So boy they, that, that’s, these shares don’t zig and zag collectively. They’re, they’re not correlated…

Properly, truly they’re as a result of they’re each giant cap development shares. And on the finish of the day. As we’ve mentioned previously, Barry, shares transfer with their, with their issue; These are each development shares. So with development shares work, these will work collectively and development shares don’t work. They received’t work collectively. So understanding the correlations is extra than simply, properly, what sector they, they, they fall into.

Barry Ritholtz: So beforehand we’ve mentioned lively share. What does that imply on the earth of concentrated portfolios? How a lot lively share do you have to make a concentrated set of holdings look completely different than the index?

Andrew Slimmon: The research present that you have to have lively share of someplace between 80 and 90 p.c, which suggests 90 p.c of your of your portfolio differs from the index.

Now I’m a believer in proudly owning shares which can be in your benchmark, however simply not proudly owning lots of them. You could possibly have a excessive lively share once more by proudly owning shares that aren’t within the index. However over time, the upper your lively share, the higher managers do, as a result of In the event you solely personal say 20 shares, it’s going to grow to be fairly obvious whether or not you’re good or not, since you’re not sort of shifting each day with the index.

And, so there may be survivorship bias, however larger lively shares confirmed to outperform decrease lively share over time.

Barry Ritholtz:  I do know you’re a fan of assorted market components like worth, high quality, and momentum. How does that match into the equation of a concentrated portfolio?

Andrew Slimmon: Simply academically, we all know that any inventory, and I’ll return to NVIDIA, it’s a giant cap, expertise, development inventory, and over time or Apple, identical factor, giant cap development expertise inventory about two thirds of its return in anyone 12 months will be outlined by these what I’d name issue exposures. Solely a 3rd comes from what’s occurring on the firm stage. So in different phrases, As a portfolio supervisor, I have to be sure that I perceive what’s going to work sooner or later. Are we in an setting the place development shares are going to work? Are we setting the place worth shares are going to work? Worth has a bit of bit extra inflation sensitivity. And so in worth shares have labored not too long ago. Um, so I feel understanding these giant components Has to play into it. I can’t simply put my blinders on and say, I’m simply going to purchase 20 shares that, you already know, I like basically, and I’m not going to have a look at anything.

I’ve seen so many managers which have made that mistake is that they. Don’t concentrate on the larger components as properly. And so we play into that. And that’s why I’m going again to that invader versus Mastercard instance, which is, uh, on the floor, two completely different sectors, however they’re each development shares and subsequently they are going to transfer with the expansion issue.

So if I’ve 20 shares and I don’t wish to have simply publicity to the expansion issue, I higher go discover one other finance inventory that’s not correlated to the expansion issue, say a financial institution or no matter.

Barry Ritholtz: Given your concentrated portfolios, 20 internationally, 30 domestically, how far more threat is contained in that small variety of shares versus your benchmarks that in some instances are 500 or 1,600 completely different names.

Andrew Slimmon: That’s true, however there are very, very giant shares within the index right now. And for those who in our international nation, we don’t personal app. Properly, Apple had a really robust first quarter. So, that added a whole lot of relative efficiency to our portfolio as a result of it’s a giant ready within the index.  I feel it’s understanding what’s the make-up of the index, and figuring out shares you suppose will work and ones in being underweight, those that received’t work.

Barry Ritholtz: And what about completely different areas? Are you able to run a concentrated portfolio with a world tilt, very separate from, from the US

Andrew Slimmon: If I mentioned to you, Barry, I wish to run a portfolio for you and I wish to simply be capable to purchase one of the best corporations I can discover that I feel I can take advantage of cash for you. And I don’t care the place they arrive from. Simply one of the best alternatives. Would you say sure to that greater than I simply, I wish to purchase solely European shares for you; or solely rising markets are solely this area or solely this model. What would you bounce at?

And I simply at all times bear in mind I used to be at a conferences about 10 years in the past and, uh, in London and this worldwide supervisor says to me, so Andrew, you run a world live performance, your international fund, how, you already know, what European banks do you spend money on? And I mentioned, I don’t have a single European financial institution. Wow. You’ll be able to’t try this. It’s in my European benchmark. I don’t like European banks both, however I bought to personal them.

And it was actually at that time, I assumed, you already know, that is loopy. Let’s simply, let’s simply discover one of the best concepts we will, you already know, all over the world and simply have a restricted variety of them.

I simply suppose that that’s, you already know, it’s a greater method than presuming that you could allocate to those particular areas or kinds as a result of managers then they’re going to purchase issues that they could not wish to personal as a result of they’re within the index.

Barry Ritholtz: You’re one of many few lively managers I’m acquainted with who appear to additionally embrace passive indexing. Inform us a bit of bit about how a concentrated portfolio matches up with a broad index.

Andrew Slimmon: Look, I’ve bought no downside with individuals getting market publicity, however there’s a place for lively administration. And I’m a believer to find nice corporations and ensuring they’re all, they’re not, um, you already know, they’re not extremely correlated and sticking with them.

What I’m completely not a fan of. Is low lively share, mutual funds that personal tons and plenty of positions. And the variety of occasions I’ve learn articles, the place somebody says, “Oh, I like this inventory. It’s my favourite place.” After which, you already know, you lookup they usually have a one and a half or 2 p.c place. Properly, it’s ridiculous as a result of even the inventory doubles, you already know, they’re not, they’re not likely, they don’t actually imagine in these corporations in the event that they personal, you already know, the small place. So I, you already know, my, the, my enemy is just not passive methods. My enemy is admittedly, uh, it’s the closet, the closet indexers as a result of I feel they’re bringing a foul identify to, you already know, to lively managers.

So I embrace passive methods. I’ve, you already know, I’ve passive methods in my private, uh, portfolio, however I’ve lively managers that I do know have finished very properly over time. And I, I’ve caught with them and you already know, it’s labored.

So there’s a spot for each. It’s simply the closet indexers is not any place for it.

Barry Ritholtz: So to wrap up, for those who’re going to go lively, properly then go lively. Personal a share of your portfolio in a concentrated set of holdings with an lively supervisor with a excessive lively share. That marries up properly to a cheap passive index and it improves the percentages of outperforming The broad indices, it might add a bit of sizzle to a conservative set of market holdings.

I’m Barry Ritholtz, and this has been Bloomberg’s At The Cash.


Print Friendly, PDF & EmailPrint Friendly, PDF & Email

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.